“It’s not my choice”: Jim Caviezel breaks his silence on being replaced as Jesus
Two decades after The Passion of the Christ, Mel Gibson has recast Jesus for The Resurrection of the Christ — but how is Jim Caviezel taking it?
Bit of a strange one, this: over twenty years since Jim Caviezel got nailed (literally and cinematically) as Jesus in Mel Gibson’s The Passion of the Christ, he’s been quietly replaced for the sequel. Not by a digital mask or fancy tech, either — Gibson thought better of all that and just hired someone else for The Resurrection of the Christ. Apparently, Caviezel's a bit miffed about the decision — who wouldn’t be, after doggedly preparing to rise from the dead again for more than a decade?
Why Caviezel Didn’t Return
Gibson, being Gibson, decided to cast Jaakko Ohtonen (best known for Vikings: Valhalla) as Jesus this time round. The logic: Caviezel’s a bit older now and digital de-aging is no cheap business. Fair enough, but it clearly rankled.
Caviezel was on Hang Out with Sean Hannity when the subject came up. He admitted he’d been mentally donning the crown of thorns for ages, but scheduling conflicts got in the way — namely, he couldn’t walk away from his other big film, Ghost Soldier. He tried to make both work, but Gibson wouldn't budge on the shooting dates.
Asked by Sean Hannity about being recast, Caviezel explained: 'I had been preparing that for over a decade, and it’s not my choice. It wasn’t the right move for me to make, I looked at the first and second screenplay. I would have had to have said no to Ghost Soldier, and I couldn’t do that. I was trying to work both of them, and he had a schedule limit and didn’t want to move it.'
So no dramatic split — more a case of business and diaries than biblical betrayal. For those wondering if Caviezel and Gibson still speak: it’s all a bit cool, apparently. Caviezel called Gibson a brilliant filmmaker but described him as 'extremely shy', and left the rest unsaid, which probably says everything that needs saying.
When Hannity pushed on their relationship now, Caviezel replied: 'I mean...we're...I think he's the greatest filmmaker I've ever worked with... I don’t think you ever get to know him. He's extremely shy guy and everything... It’s a funny business our business.'
The New Cast & Release Dates
This time, Ohtonen picks up the cross as Jesus with Mariela Garriga (Mission: Impossible – The Final Reckoning) joining as Mary Magdalene. And, yes, they’re apparently stretching this latest biblical yarn into two films: the first part lands in cinemas 6 May 2027, and the second follows on 25 May 2028.
The Resurrection of the Christ is coming as a two-parter: Part One in May 2027 and Part Two at the end of the same month in 2028.
Caviezel’s Other Gig
As for what kept Caviezel occupied instead, Ghost Soldier just hit theatres. Caviezel stars as Fitz, a not-so-legal weapons designer/ex-Green Beret who goes toe-to-toe with mercenaries trying to turf people out of his Wyoming hometown. It’s all quite retro — think old-school action from the 80s and 90s (whether you prefer that or not is your call). Our own Chris Bumbray gave it a mostly positive nod, saying it feels like a throwback, though he thought it really should have gone for an R-rating, given all the inventive weaponry on display. Rated as 'more violent than something a faith-based studio like Angel would put out', but could have done with a splash more bloody spectacle.