George R.R. Martin says this HBO show has the best finale in TV history — and it isn’t Game of Thrones
George R.R. Martin has singled out an HBO TV series for praise, lauding its five-season run and standout finale — with plenty of other memorable touches to boot.
Finales are tricky beasts, aren’t they? Everyone remembers their favourite show for the ending — the triumphs, the brilliant callbacks, and, sometimes, the utter disappointment. But some land it so perfectly you barely remember the missteps on the way. Ask around about classic TV endings and you’ll hear the names: Mad Men, Friends, Cheers. But apparently, that’s not the actual top tier if you ask a rather expert source.
Martin Weighs In
In the summer of 2023, George R.R. Martin — yes, the bloke who penned Game of Thrones and knows a thing or two about TV disasters and delights — took to his own website (which is, in a very Martin move, titled “not a blog”) after reading Vanity Fair’s round-up of the best TV episodes from the last quarter-century. Amidst the list, he singled out one finale as the absolute peak.
Here’s what Martin wrote on his site:
if I had to pick one episode that was even more perfect than all the others on the list, though, it would have to be the final episode of SIX FEET UNDER. I liked that series well enough, though I cannot say I loved it as much as I loved ROME or DEADWOOD or FARGO or a few other shows missing from the list, but that last episode was far and away the best finale in the entire history of television, and I cannot imagine how anyone could possibly do better.
Say what you like about Martin’s pacing, but when he names a best-ever TV ending, people do pay attention. He’s not the only fan either — when Six Feet Under wrapped up in 2005, just shy of 3.9 million viewers tuned in live, so it wasn’t exactly niche telly.
Six Feet Under drew nearly 3.9 million live viewers for its 2005 finale episode.
What Made the Fisher Family Special?
Six Feet Under ran on HBO from 2001 to 2005 and took a rather bold tack: every episode starts with somebody dying. That might sound a bit bleak, but for the Fisher family — LA funeral directors perpetually dodging their own mortality while cleaning up other people’s — it gave the writers the opportunity to thread grief, love, ambition, and occasionally the most unexpected bits of comedy through every week.
The finale, “Everyone’s Waiting,” is a genuine all-timer (I refuse to oversell, but it’s about as close as telly gets). Ruth (Frances Conroy), her sons Nate (Peter Krause) and David (Michael C. Hall), as well as their respective partners and siblings, all get proper closure. The episode’s final montage — set to Sia’s “Breathe Me” — shows you how each major character’s story plays out. It’s the kind of sequence you think about for days, hovering somewhere between uplifting and unspeakably tear-jerking, never tipping all the way into sentimentality or nihilism.
Every family member gets a moment, but it’s Claire (Lauren Ambrose) who carries the heart of the thing, trying to forge her way in the world when everyone else seems to be falling apart. If you’ve ever been young and ready to dash out into the unknown, it hits painfully close.
Longevity and Quality
It’s not just the ending. The entire run of Six Feet Under still holds up nearly two decades on: packed with top-drawer writing, consistently strong performances, and a tone that’s deeply human without preaching at you. If you want numbers, the show averages an 81% rating on Rotten Tomatoes.
- Season 1 – 90%
- Season 2 – 79%
- Season 3 – 90%
- Season 4 – 50% (yes, rough patch, it happens)
- Season 5 – 97%
So, you do get a wobble in series four — it’s the classic ‘darkest before dawn’ sort of slump, not unwatchable by any stretch, but moodier than usual. Even then, most reckon it’s worth slogging through for the final pay-off.
Current HBO programming gets loads of buzz, but every few years people rediscover Six Feet Under and rave all over again about how it’s more than a show about death — it’s a surprisingly uplifting meditation on why life (and friends, and family) matter to start with.