Movies

Nicolas Cage’s Madden lands on Prime Video with a brutal 15% Rotten Tomatoes score

Nicolas Cage’s Madden lands on Prime Video with a brutal 15% Rotten Tomatoes score
Image credit: Google Veo 3

David O. Russell’s new sports biopic has taken a thumping on arrival, with critics and audiences uniting to slap it with a rotten rating.

Oven-ready turkeys, parades on telly, and a bit of American football: that’s the typical US Thanksgiving recipe. And now, Prime Video wants to add a sports biopic to the menu with Madden, a film that sounds like it should be a safe bet but, judging by the reviews, may be more of a fumble than a touchdown.

Madden arrives on Prime Video 18 November 2026, a week ahead of its original Thanksgiving slot.

From Ferrell to Cage: A Messy Journey

David O. Russell — back for his first project since his last outing Amsterdam underwhelmed at the box office — is in the director’s chair for this one. The plot is a biographical spin on legendary football coach John Madden and his unlikely legacy as the name behind the Madden NFL video game franchise, if you can believe it. The film’s cast list is wild enough to turn heads: Nicolas Cage as Madden, Christian Bale, Kathryn Hahn, John Mulaney, Sienna Miller, Joel Murray, Shane Gillis, and Miles Burris.

This one’s had a bit of a time getting to screens. Announced back in 2023, it was actually set to feature Will Ferrell leading, which might have made for a totally different vibe. Instead, Nic Cage swooped in August 2024. Shooting lined up for 2025 and, after a bit of calendar shuffling, the premiere was moved up from Thanksgiving Day — presumably to dodge the Black Friday streaming stampede and tempt viewers earlier.

Scoring Reviews: Not Exactly a Win

If Prime Video was hoping Madden would kick off the holiday viewing in style, the critics have other ideas. It’s limped onto Rotten Tomatoes with an eye-watering low of 15% from 13 early reviews, which is about as rough as it gets for a high-profile sports drama. For comparison, that’s well below expectations for pretty much anything not starring a cartoon animal.

  • Charles Papadopoulos at Movie Web handed over a lukewarm 2.5 out of 5, basically accusing the film of not figuring out if it wants to be a serious biopic or a comedy about blokes in tracksuits.
  • Owen Gleiberman at Variety was a bit gentler, saying the film at least lets you 'touch the buzz of Russell’s intelligence', even if the whole thing feels a bit scruffy.
  • Vikram Murthi at IndieWire was very much not amused, dishing out a D+ and lamenting that the director who made I Heart Huckabees seems long gone, replaced by someone turning out what’s effectively a branding exercise in film form.

On the acting front, there’s more bad news. David Rooney from The Hollywood Reporter argued the performances are, frankly, a bit much: cartoonish, self-aware, and impossible to forget you’re watching actors working very hard to act. On the other hand, Matthew Rudoy at Screen Rant found something to like in the dynamic between the two leads and scored it a passable 6 out of 10.

The Streaming Scrimmage

Madden isn’t the only sports flick in Prime Video’s locker this Thanksgiving — and it’s not looking like the champion. Amazon MGM's I Play Rocky is opening in cinemas on 6 November (wide release 20 November) and has a far more respectable 87% on Rotten Tomatoes, with 147 reviews. And Netflix is getting in on the act, too, with its own football drama The Mosquito Bowl landing on 25 November, sitting on a 44% Rotten Tomatoes score — still three times better than Madden.

Liz Shannon Miller at Consequence sums up the mood with a C+ review, suggesting Madden should have been a Redbox exclusive — and noting, somewhat pointedly, that Redbox isn't even around anymore.

CineCorner UK use of cookies We use necessary cookies to make our site work. We'd also like to set analytics cookies that help us make improvements by measuring how you use the site. These will be set only if you accept. For more detailed information about the cookies we use, see our Cookie Policy