TV

This eerie new mystery mixes Twin Peaks with Sherlock — and puts Baba Yaga on the case

This eerie new mystery mixes Twin Peaks with Sherlock — and puts Baba Yaga on the case
Image credit: Film still

If 'Twin Peaks' and 'Sherlock' are your benchmark for smart TV mystery thrillers, a new series earns its place alongside them — and it’s well worth your attention.

Not every day you get a series built around Baba Yaga, the chicken-legged hut-dweller straight out of Slavic nightmares. Yet here we are: Yaga, a new Crave original, has landed with all the supernatural oddness and dark humour you’d hope for, and honestly, it’s better than most of the “quirky detective” shows that keep sprouting up. Americans get it via AMC+, so you lot aren’t missing out.

At the heart of it, creator Kat Sandler told Toronto Life about her approach: "At the time, television was obsessed with male anti-heroes, like Dexter or Hannibal, so I liked the idea of creating a female anti-hero who could be just as entertaining. A woman who is technically doing evil things but has her own moral code."

It’s not your standard cop drama – and thank god for that – though you can draw a few lines to Twin Peaks (the small-town strangeness, the surreal clues) and a touch of Sherlock snark in the leads’ back-and-forth. Still, it’s a proper original take – and despite the Russian folklore roots, the series manages to mix human drama and magical weirdness in a way that, somehow, mostly works.

The Setup: Small Town, Big Weirdness

Every episode, clocking in at around half an hour, begins with Baba Yaga herself as narrator – you never quite know if she’ll come off the sidelines and mess with the main story or just linger in the shadows. It’s a clever device: you’re always aware there’s more going on than the usual whodunit.

The main plot’s as follows: Private investigator Charlie Rapp (Noah Reid) rocks up in an oddly sleepy lakeside town after being called in about the sudden disappearance of flash businessman Henry Park (Hudson Williams). What’s immediately fun: Williams also plays Henry’s skint roommate, Logan Casey – identical, except for the bank balance. Not just a gag, it’s a knot in the central mystery as well. Alongside Rapp, there’s Sergeant Carson (Clark Backo), the local cop with enough patience for Rapp’s peculiar methods. Their energy together – somewhere between wary mates and chalk-and-cheese partners – keeps the story buzzing along.

Carrie-Anne Moss drops in as academic boss Dr. Katherine Hargrove – a bones-and-animals expert who knows far more than she’s letting on. Katherine, by the way, is straight out of the Baba Yaga playbook: larger than life, magnetic, and living by her own rules.

Yaga premiered 23 October 2026, with eight half-hour episodes to its name.

The staging and setting are part of the fun. Where the original play was performed with nothing more than pretend trees, a couple of seats and a desk (Tarragon Theater, Toronto, 2019, if you need a pub quiz fact), the show goes full ham on moody scenery, fog off the lake, and the sort of town where everything looks slightly haunted. Not that the show forgets its theatrical roots: the writing leans heavily on dialogue, so there’s less faff, more bite.

What Makes It Stick

The mystery itself is a notch or two stranger than your average BBC detective yarn. Things get odd – feathers at crime scenes, locals who know more than they’re telling, and an atmosphere that leaves you suspecting the trees might join the investigation if you look away too long. The banter helps – Rapp and Carson balance jabs with proper character work, before the daft becomes dangerous.

  • Noah Reid as PI Charlie Rapp
  • Clark Backo as Sergeant Carson
  • Hudson Williams as Henry Park / Logan Casey
  • Carrie-Anne Moss as Dr. Katherine Hargrove

Some of the best moments veer away from typical procedural territory; Rapp, for instance, has a habit of getting coffee orders wrong on purpose to study people’s reactions. Small, but it tells you volumes about how his brain works. Carson, meanwhile, gets a line about how 'it’s the small, boring stuff that gets big fast for real people,' which more or less sums up the emotional heart underneath the witchy weirdness. She’s the grounding force, the one with both feet on the ground while everyone else seems on the verge of floating off into the mist.

If you’re after something with less endless exposition and more sly wit and actual mystery, Yaga isn’t a bad way to spend your next binge. The case pulls you in, the supernatural twitches give you chills, and it’s just surreal enough to feel fresh, not forced. There’s a confidence here – maybe from knowing it started as a bare-bones play – that makes it worth a look, even if you think you’ve seen every possible missing-person drama already.

CineCorner UK use of cookies We use necessary cookies to make our site work. We'd also like to set analytics cookies that help us make improvements by measuring how you use the site. These will be set only if you accept. For more detailed information about the cookies we use, see our Cookie Policy