Sony wants Spider-Man in the Best Picture race — the Oscar odds tell another story
Sony Pictures is gearing up an Oscar campaign for Spider-Man: Brand New Day — with eyes on a prize you probably weren’t expecting.
Here we go again — Spider-Man at the Oscars. Sony’s biggest web-slinger, Brand New Day, has managed to smash box office records and even keep critics happy. But is that enough for Oscar to give it a nod for Best Picture? Sony Pictures isn’t leaving it to chance; they’re prepping a full-blown awards campaign, and their boss doesn’t seem shy about saying the film should be in contention.
Brand New Day is the highest-grossing movie in American history, but Sony’s Tom Rothman thinks its quality is what matters for the Academy: ‘Are you telling me that there are 10 films this year that are better than this film?’
Oscar Hopes and Market Realities
The man beating this particular drum is Tom Rothman, CEO at Sony Pictures. He’s gone on record that, in his opinion, Brand New Day isn’t just a box office behemoth, but an objectively great film — one of the year’s absolute best. While making the rounds to rally people for the campaign, Rothman’s putting the question to Hollywood: is anyone really convinced there’ve been 10 better films released all year? He thinks not, and he’s ready to make some noise about it.
- Spider-Man: Brand New Day is sitting in the 90s for both critic and audience scores on Rotten Tomatoes.
- The film has reportedly done nearly a billion dollars at the US box office alone.
- Despite the acclaim and giant numbers, Oscar prediction trackers like Gold Derby currently rank it #36 on the list of Best Picture contenders. It’s not even close to cracking the top ten in their odds.
Rothman argues the Academy expanded Best Picture nominations from five to ten specifically so “quality commercial filmmaking” would be recognised — and, if those are the rules, he reckons Brand New Day deserves its shot as much as the so-called ‘art films’
Superheroes and Statuettes
Now, if you follow Oscars history at all, you’ll know superhero movies don’t tend to land Best Picture nods — the outliers being Black Panther and Joker, and that’s basically it. Rothman doesn’t expect the old guard at the Academy to change overnight, but he’s keen to point out he’s no stranger to art films, having earned his reputation at Searchlight. Still, he claims the point of the expanded nominations was to open the doors to genuinely excellent commercial movies. And if Brand New Day doesn’t count as one of those, he asks, what does?