Madden scored 15% on Rotten Tomatoes. It still took No. 1 on Prime Video in the US
One of the year’s worst‑reviewed films — a major Christian Bale biopic — has somehow topped a streaming chart.
Ever get the feeling audiences and critics are watching completely different films? Case in point: Madden is absolutely storming the streaming charts right now, even though most reviewers have been less than kind. And when I say 'less than kind', I mean some have genuinely torched the thing.
Madden hit the number one spot on Prime Video's Top 10 Movies chart in the US on 19 November 2026.
Brilliant Cast, Bleak Reviews
This one's not short on star power or experienced hands. David O. Russell directs (that's the chap behind Silver Linings Playbook and American Hustle, for what it’s worth), and the cast is stacked: Nicolas Cage playing football coaching legend John Madden, Christian Bale as his mate-rival Al Davis, Kathryn Hahn as Virginia Madden, Sienna Miller as Carol Davis, and even John Mulaney popping up as Trip Hawkins. Amazon MGM Studios put it all out, R rating and all.
On paper, you'd expect it to be an awards-bait slam dunk, but critics have gone for it like defenders on a bad pass. At last check, Rotten Tomatoes had Madden at a truly dire 15% from 33 critic reviews. Audiences were a little more forgiving—Popcornmeter showing 55% from 100+ regular viewers—which, frankly, makes you wonder if critics watched this through a different set of eyes (or possibly a paper bag).
Plot and Platform Details
If you're wondering what it's actually about—the film is a sort of potted life story, following Madden's journey alongside best mate Al Davis, charting their partnership at the Raiders, Super Bowl glory, and right through to the birth of the Madden NFL video game empire.
- Title: Madden
- Main cast: Nicolas Cage (John Madden), Christian Bale (Al Davis), Kathryn Hahn (Virginia Madden), Sienna Miller (Carol Davis), John Mulaney (Trip Hawkins)
- Director: David O. Russell
- Distributor: Amazon MGM Studios
- Streaming status: Now available on Prime Video; also in limited cinema release
Reviewers in Open Revolt
This is where it gets brutal. Andrew Lawrence (The Guardian) said it was closer to, wait for it, 'the Pop Tarts movie version' of a football legend's life—hardly what you want if you’re after the next 'Air'. Manohla Dargis at the New York Times reckoned Russell was treating 'hard truths' like interchangeable little gags. IGN’s Jim Vejvoda tossed it a 4/10, pointing out that even with Cage and Bale onboard, both 'Oscar winners couldn't rise above caricature'. Ouch.
Robert Daniels at RogerEbert.com delivered the death blow: zero out of four, declaring this film the absolute low point of Russell’s work. On the other hand, there was the odd voice of support: Charles Koplinski (Reel Talk) went 3.5 out of 4, praising its portrayal of 'the essence of the man'. Simon Foster (Screen-Space) also gave 3.5 out of 5, reckoning the film’s 'singular eccentricity' fit Madden’s story perfectly. So, not a universal panning, just a heavily lopsided one.
Strange times: a majorly-derided film, enormous cast, and director with Oscar cred… yet here it is, Number 1 on Prime Video and climbing high on the overall chart. It’s not boring, at any rate.