Sarah Paulson Reveals Her Least Favourite Role on Screen

Sarah Paulson is often hailed as one of the most talented actors in the industry, with a career marked by a string of memorable roles. Yet, despite the widespread recognition she has received, Paulson has not shied away from voicing her dissatisfaction with a particular part that many consider among her best. Her frankness is all the more striking given her reputation for complete dedication to her work.

Ryan Murphy Collaborations and Career Milestones

Ryan Murphy’s television projects have long divided opinion, with his bold, sometimes excessive approach drawing both admiration and criticism. Murphy’s ability to attract top-tier talent is rarely in doubt, and Paulson has become synonymous with his productions. Their professional relationship began with a minor appearance in Nip/Tuck, but it was her recurring roles in the anthology series American Horror Story that cemented her status as Murphy’s go-to collaborator.

Paulson’s career trajectory shifted dramatically when she portrayed Marcia Clark in the Murphy-produced miniseries American Crime Story: The People vs. O.J. Simpson. The series revisited the infamous trial, offering fresh insight into the individuals at its centre. Paulson’s nuanced depiction of the lead prosecutor earned her widespread acclaim and her first Primetime Emmy Award, a significant milestone in her career.

Disappointment with American Horror Story: Roanoke

Despite the professional high of playing Marcia Clark, Paulson soon discovered that not every project would prove as fulfilling. She found herself returning to American Horror Story for the Roanoke season, an experience she later described as deeply unsatisfying. In a candid roundtable discussion with Scott Feinberg, Paulson admitted,

I just don’t care about this season at all. I know people will get mad at me for saying it. To me, this was post-having played Marcia. It was what I went to do right after finishing Marcia and I was so underwhelmed by the whole experience.

Her comments reflect a broader frustration with the series, which has often muddled its own continuity by having actors reappear in new roles each season. While Paulson’s earlier performances in Murder House and Asylum were met with enthusiasm, the response to Roanoke was notably subdued, and she found little satisfaction in the process.

Loyalty Amidst Creative Challenges

Paulson’s willingness to speak openly about her disappointment is unusual in an industry where actors are often expected to remain diplomatic. Nevertheless, she has continued to work with Murphy, demonstrating a sense of loyalty despite her misgivings. Even as the following season, Cult, failed to win over critics, Paulson delivered another standout performance in the third series of American Crime Story, Impeachment, where she was praised for her portrayal of Linda Tripp.

Murphy’s productions remain a source of debate, with his latest anthology, Monster, facing accusations of sensationalising real-life tragedies. Still, Paulson appears to remain a fixture in his creative circle, having featured in projects such as Feud: Bette and Joan and Ratched. For better or worse, their professional partnership seems set to continue.