Nicole Wallace is done playing Noah: My Fault's fourth book could go to the London remake
The new novel jumps Nick and Noah years ahead, and the actress who made Noah famous says she can't see herself in it. Its author isn't too worried about that.
Nicole Wallace won't be racing back as Noah any time soon. In a Deadline cover interview published on 13 October 2026, the star of Culpa mía, Culpa tuya and Culpa nuestra said a return in a possible fourth film "would feel very weird". She hasn't read Mercedes Ron's new book, and nobody has asked her to come back.
Her reasons are practical rather than dramatic. The new novel jumps years ahead, and Wallace doesn't see herself in it: "They're much older and I just don't think I would connect to it in the same way." She said goodbye properly at the premiere of the third film last year.
"I did close a chapter and go through the grief of letting it go and remembering the good parts and the bad parts."
— Nicole Wallace, to Deadline
That is a big exit from a big franchise. Prime Video says the three Spanish films have been watched by more than 100 million people, and Culpa tuya was the streamer's biggest international launch when it arrived in 2024.
A fourth book and no Spanish Noah
Ron published Culpa vuestra (Their Fault) in Spanish in May 2026, about a decade after she finished the original trilogy. It picks up Nick and Noah years later, which is exactly the version of Noah that Wallace says she can't connect to.
Ron, though, wants it filmed, and in September she was already looking past any single cast. Speaking to Deadline for its International Disruptors series, she said:
"The good thing is that we have a Spanish version and an English version. I'm happy if any of them want to adapt the fourth book."
— Mercedes Ron, author of the Culpables books
She added that "right now, there's nothing on the table", but called it "an easy book to adapt" with "all the ingredients to make this movie work". Read the two interviews side by side and the author has, politely, left the door open to London.
Read more: Amanda Seyfried stripped at 19 to keep her job: now a whole series isn't worth it
The London timetable
The English remakes moved the story from Spain to Britain, with Asha Banks and Matthew Broome as Noah and Nick and Dani Girdwood and Charlotte Fassler directing. On paper, their calendar lines up neatly with the new book:
- 2025: My Fault: London arrives on Prime Video.
- June 2026: Your Fault: London follows, with the same leads.
- 2027: Our Fault: London, the end of the English trilogy, has wrapped and is due out.
- 2027: Culpa vuestra is published in English.
So the British trilogy finishes in the same year English-speaking readers get the next chapter. If Prime wants a fourth film, the London cast would be the one with the momentum, while the Spanish leads have moved on. Wallace herself is a fan of the replacement: Banks "had a lot of fun with it and made her a little bit different than my Noah", she said.
Culpa vuestra has its author's blessing, an English edition due in 2027 and, for now, no Noah.
None of that is a decision, and Deadline is clear about it: on the fourth film, "nothing is confirmed". No studio has announced an adaptation, and nobody has said which Noah would play the older version.
Life after Noah
Wallace isn't short of work. She plays Clara in The House of the Spirits, Prime Video's series based on Isabel Allende's novel, and leads Postcards From Italy, a comedy from Oscar winner Jessica Yu and her first English-language project to reach audiences. Next is Throttled, a romance set in a fictional Formula 1, opposite Josh Heuston, with Wallace as a driver's sister who falls for his rival.
So Noah's Porsche is parked, and Wallace is off to the paddock. Whether the next Noah gets behind the wheel is now up to Prime Video, and, by the look of the calendar, possibly to London.
Read more: 'Nice to have': Netflix shrugs off losing Harry Potter and Batman with a Canadian sea monster