Joaquin Phoenix’s Joker: The Unlikely Inspiration Behind His Oscar Win

Joaquin Phoenix’s portrayal of the Joker in Todd Phillips’ film offered audiences a version of the character that felt entirely fresh, steering clear of the well-trodden paths set by his predecessors. The Joker, a figure both infamous and coveted in the world of fiction, has long attracted actors eager to leave their mark. Cesar Romero first donned the villain’s grin in the original Batman television series, while Jack Nicholson’s flamboyant turn in Tim Burton’s 1989 film and Mark Hamill’s chilling voice work in the animated series each added new layers to the role. Heath Ledger’s haunting performance in The Dark Knight, which posthumously earned him an Academy Award, seemed to set an insurmountable standard. Jared Leto’s later attempt in Suicide Squad failed to capture the same magic, making the prospect of another memorable Joker seem rather unlikely. Yet, Phoenix took up the challenge, bringing a bold new vision to the screen.

Unlike typical comic book adaptations, Joker reimagined Gotham as a gritty, tangible city reminiscent of 1970s New York, echoing the atmosphere of Martin Scorsese’s films. Batman was nowhere to be seen; instead, Phoenix embodied a solitary, troubled man who gradually assumes the Joker persona after enduring relentless hardship and alienation. The film sparked debate for its handling of mental health and social unrest, but it quickly became one of the most discussed releases of 2019, even breaking records as the first R-rated film to surpass $1 billion at the box office. Despite polarising opinions, Phoenix’s performance was widely acknowledged as extraordinary, earning him the Academy Award for Best Actor. What set his interpretation apart was its originality and unexpected empathy, a departure from the familiar approaches of Romero, Nicholson, Hamill, and Ledger.

Tracing the Roots of Phoenix’s Performance

Rather than drawing inspiration from previous Jokers, Phoenix looked elsewhere for guidance. He revealed that his approach was shaped by a performer from a different era altogether.

“I think what influenced me the most was Ray Bolger,” Phoenix told the Associated Press, “There was a particular song called ‘The Old Soft Shoe’ that he performed, and I saw a video of it, and there’s this odd arrogance almost to his movements and

”

Bolger, best remembered for his role as the Scarecrow in The Wizard of Oz, was renowned for his distinctive physical style and expressive movement. Phoenix was captivated by Bolger’s performance, particularly the way he carried himself with a peculiar blend of confidence and awkwardness. This unique physicality became a cornerstone of Phoenix’s own interpretation, informing the Joker’s mannerisms and presence on screen.

Redefining a Legendary Villain

Phoenix’s decision to channel Bolger rather than echo the work of previous Jokers allowed him to craft a character that felt both unsettling and oddly sympathetic. The result was a portrayal that stood apart from the rest, rooted in classic performance yet entirely modern in its execution. By borrowing from Bolger’s repertoire, Phoenix managed to sidestep the shadow of those who came before him, instead offering a Joker that was unmistakably his own.

His approach not only paid homage to a forgotten star but also demonstrated the enduring power of physical performance in cinema. In doing so, Phoenix delivered a Joker that was as memorable for its subtlety as for its intensity, earning both critical acclaim and a place in film history.