How accurate is The Pacific? Checked against the two Marines' memoirs it was built on

HBO spent $217 million on ten hours of the Pacific war and built almost all of it from two books written by men who were there. The third lead never wrote one, which is where the seams show.

The series ran from 14 March to 16 May 2010, produced by Steven Spielberg, Tom Hanks and Gary Goetzman, with Hugh Ambrose consulting. Its primary sources are Eugene Sledge's With the Old Breed: At Peleliu and Okinawa, published in 1981, and Robert Leckie's Helmet for My Pillow, published in 1957. It also draws on Sledge's second book, China Marine, and on Chuck Tatum's Red Blood, Black Sand for the John Basilone strand. All three leads were real men in the 1st Marine Division, serving in three different regiments.

What the memoirs back up

The uncomfortable material is the accurate material. Souvenir-hunting — prising gold teeth from corpses, stripping bodies for flags and weapons — is documented in both books as ordinary post-battle routine. Snafu Shelton idly dropping pebbles into the open skull of a dead Japanese gunner is, if anything, at the mild end of what the two men describe.

Read more: Mutiny on the Bounty true story: what the 1789 record says that three Hollywood versions didn't

The series also declines to film some of it. Both Sledge and Leckie record coming across American dead who had been mutilated after death; neither incident is staged on screen.

The crocodiles in the Tenaru River got a pass. Leckie wrote that his unit never shot at them, on the reasoning that no enemy would swim past a river patrol like that.

Where the series rearranges the books

• Sledge and Leckie meeting on Pavuvu — invented. Sledge never mentions encountering Leckie, though he does cite one of Leckie's later history books as a source for the background sections of his own.
• The gold teeth scene — on screen, Snafu talks Sledge out of it. In With the Old Breed, the man who stops him is corpsman Kent Caswell, who doesn't appear in the series at all.
• Sledge's heart murmur — the series makes it the reason he can't enlist alongside Sidney Phillips in 1942. His memoir gives a less cinematic account: his father and brother steered him into college, he was placed in the V-12 officer training programme at Georgia Tech, and he and half his detachment flunked out on purpose rather than miss the war.
• Okinawa — Part Nine departs substantially from the sequence and emphasis of Sledge's own chapters.

Leckie's breakdown

The strangest-sounding thread is the true one. After Cape Gloucester, Leckie develops nocturnal enuresis, is diagnosed by a corpsman, and is sent to a field hospital on Banika, where a psychiatrist tells him he mostly checks people out and sends them back. Leckie recorded the condition and the hospital stay himself. The series adds surrounding material — Lieutenant Lebec's suicide, Gibson strangling a prisoner — as pressure that explains it.

Vera Keller, the neighbour Leckie barely knows in the first episode, was real. They married after the war. She died in 2024.

Leckie's stated reason for writing the book was that he walked out of a Broadway performance of South Pacific halfway through. People needed to know, he said, that the war wasn't a musical.

The Basilone problem

Basilone earned the Medal of Honor on Guadalcanal in October 1942, was sent home to sell war bonds, hated it, and pushed to be returned to training duty and then to combat. At Camp Pendleton he met Sergeant Lena Riggi of the Marine Corps Women's Reserve, a field cook; they married in July 1944. He was killed on Iwo Jima on 19 February 1945 and received a posthumous Navy Cross. Riggi christened the destroyer USS Basilone in 1949.

None of that comes from Basilone. He left no memoir, so his third of the series is assembled from Tatum's book, service records and interviews — which is why his episodes feel more like conventional war drama than Sledge's or Leckie's do.

For the record: Sledge wrote the notes that became With the Old Breed in the margins of a pocket New Testament, because diaries were banned at the front. He published the book in 1981, thirty-six years after Okinawa.

Earlier we wrote: Who was on NCIS from the beginning? Only one of the original cast is still in the credits more than two decades on