Bollywood Legend Once Approached for Dumbledore Role

As HBO presses ahead with its much-discussed Harry Potter television adaptation, a rather intriguing detail from the original film series has come to light. During a Twitter Q&A with The Times of India, it emerged that Naseeruddin Shah, a celebrated figure in Indian cinema, was once invited to try out for the role of Albus Dumbledore following the death of Richard Harris.

My agent wanted me to audition for Dumbledore’s character after Richard Harris died. I was asked if I would like to audition for it. But I wouldn’t audition for it.

Shah explained that his agent encouraged him to pursue the part after Harris, who had portrayed the Hogwarts headmaster in the first two instalments, passed away. Despite the suggestion, Shah declined to audition. The role ultimately went to Michael Gambon, who would go on to play the character in the remaining six films.

Barriers to Casting: The British-Only Policy

Although Shah had previously appeared in Hollywood productions, such as The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen, his prospects of securing the part were always rather limited. The Harry Potter franchise maintained a strict policy of casting only British and Irish actors, a rule that would have excluded Shah regardless of his willingness to audition.

Warner Bros. had previously turned down even the likes of Robin Williams, who was reportedly keen to play either Rubeus Hagrid or Remus Lupin. Despite his suitability, Williams was rejected in order to preserve the films’ distinctly British character. At the time, J.K. Rowling was closely involved in the casting process and was determined to ensure the Wizarding World remained culturally authentic. This made it highly unlikely that an actor from outside the UK or Ireland would be chosen for such a pivotal role.

Changing Times: New Approaches to Casting

Today, the landscape appears to be shifting. The upcoming HBO series is said to be adopting a more inclusive approach, with John Lithgow, an American, already confirmed to play Dumbledore. This marks a significant departure from the earlier casting philosophy and suggests that international actors like Shah might now have a genuine opportunity to join the franchise.

Back in the early 2000s, however, the combination of studio policy and Rowling’s involvement meant that even a highly respected Bollywood star would have faced insurmountable obstacles. The franchise’s commitment to authenticity was, at the time, unwavering.

Other Contenders for the Hogwarts Headmaster

Following Harris’s death, the search for a new Dumbledore was extensive. The studio considered several distinguished actors, each capable of bringing their own gravitas to the role. Among those reportedly in the running were Ian McKellen, already well-known for his portrayal of Gandalf, as well as Peter O’Toole, Christopher Lee, Sean Connery, and Patrick McGoohan.

Despite the impressive shortlist, none of these names ultimately took on the part. Michael Gambon was selected, and his interpretation of the character became a defining feature of the later films. Since then, Jude Law has also portrayed the headmaster in the Fantastic Beasts series, and now John Lithgow is set to take up the mantle in the new adaptation.

The Enduring Legacy of Dumbledore

Throughout the Harry Potter saga, the character of Albus Dumbledore has remained central, both beloved and, at times, divisive among fans. The pressure to recast after Harris’s passing was considerable, and the eventual choice of Gambon proved to be a significant moment for the franchise. With the series continuing to evolve, audiences are left to reflect on the many actors who have shaped the role and to consider who, among them, stands as their favourite.

Harry Potter is currently available to stream in the US on HBO Max.

This post belongs to FandomWire and first appeared on FandomWire