The Rings of Power adds a chilling new step to becoming a Nazgûl — Tolkien never wrote it
Prime Video’s Tolkien show complicates the path to becoming a Ringwraith, inserting a fresh stage for its villains between their days as Men and their final forms.
Look, I appreciate a bit of creative meddling when it comes to beloved source material — as long as you can justify it. The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power has been taking some fairly bold liberties with Tolkien since episode one, and if you're bothered by that sort of thing, well... this might not help. But if you're willing to roll with it, there's some genuinely intriguing stuff in how the show is handling the rise of the Nazgûl as Season 3 approaches.
The Nine Rings for Men have already surfaced on screen, meaning the show's just about ready to introduce its take on Middle-earth's most infamous undead servants.
Nazgûl, But Not As You Know Them
So here's the setup: At the tail end of season two, Sauron gets his slippery mitts on the Nine Rings meant for Men, so naturally, everyone's waiting for the Nazgûl to show. But rather than just plonking the Ringwraiths into the story as the black-robed horrors we know from the films, The Rings of Power is rewinding the horror a bit — showing what these corrupted blokes were actually like before vanishing up Sauron's sleeve. This isn't something Tolkien ever spelled out. In the books, by the time we meet the Nazgûl, they're properly wraith-like and bordering on faceless — all personality sucked out, only really memorable because of the Witch-king and (if you're deeply nerdy) Khamûl the Easterling.
But the showrunners have crafted an extra stage: enter the Nazgnagôl. These are men who've just started going over to the dark side. Still physically human under those cloaks, masks pulled tight, but already displaying unnerving strength and almost Sauron-level resilience. They're already bound to Sauron's will, yet haven't lost every scrap of agency; they're not just hollow shells quite yet. The writers have leaned into this — for instance, Theo actually begs Arondir to leg it before Theo can be manipulated into violence. It's a neat twist: the descent's not instant, and we get to watch them lose themselves piece by piece.
Season 3's depiction of the Nazgnagôl steers well outside Tolkien's text, letting the show explore what evil actually does to a person before they're lost entirely.
Tinkering Everywhere, Not Just Here
Of course, this is all part of a much broader trend with The Rings of Power. The show flat out loves fiddling with Tolkien's timeline, compressing centuries into months, bringing the Istari (that's the wizards) to Middle-earth early, and giving the Orcs backstories that go beyond 'they're bad, and that’s that'. This time round, the showrunners seem determined to give Sauron's lieutenants an actual arc, fleshing out how they went from ordinary Men with choices, to Sauron's absolute thralls. Even Sauron's own motivations are getting a good polish. The idea, clearly, is to crank up the tragedy — to show that before they became monsters, the Nazgûl had the option to walk away, but didn't.