The Rings of Power scrapped an entire subplot because its four-legged star wouldn’t behave
The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power Season 3 binned a major plotline after one on-set ‘actor’ refused to cooperate — and it’s not who you think.
When you picture troublesome actors on a fantasy epic, you might be thinking difficult divas or a method type refusing to take off their elf ears. But for The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power Season 3, it wasn't a human causing headaches—it was a dog. Yes, you read that right. The team had to scrap an entire subplot because their four-legged co-star wasn't having it. The whole thing is equal parts tragic and completely ridiculous.
The dog meant for a recurring role in Season 3 ended up causing so many problems on set that the producers had to junk most of its storylines.
How the canine chaos started
Co-showrunner Patrick McKay spilled the beans in a sit-down with Collider Behind the Scenes, explaining that the production genuinely wanted their elf warrior Arondir to have a furry companion. Apparently, a particularly moving scene had been mapped out where Galadriel comes home from battle—everyone else is reunited with family, loved ones, or in Arondir's case, his trusty hound. The idea: Galadriel stands alone, and the audience feels that loneliness.
According to McKay, that dog wasn't just meant to be background fluff, either—they'd had big plans. The mutt would have shown up again later on, possibly getting some comic business interacting with Orcs (now there's a deleted scene I'd pay to see). But reality comes for us all, even in Middle-earth. McKay didn't hold back on the chaos:
McKay described their intentions and frustrations like this: "But the idea that this dog would be in many scenes and be a source of humour and interact with the Orc, and I think we even had an idea of bringing the dog back later in the season. No, that dog was an absolute nightmare."
Looks aren't everything
Director Charlotte Brändström added more detail, saying the dog was a perfect lookalike for what they'd imagined—tick for casting, at least. But if you've ever tried to get a dog to do what you want when you actually need them to, you'll know what's coming. She explained that while the dog was picture-perfect, it never sat still long enough for them to actually get the footage. They just about got him to gnaw on a prop bone—and that, apparently, was the highlight of his career.
- Arondir's dog was planned as a recurring character in several episodes
- Early storylines had him alongside major cast, including Galadriel
- The animal's inability to cooperate forced writers and directors to abandon its plot
- Some scenes were shot, but most were dropped due to repeated filming problems