Spider-Man Fans Split Over Zendaya’s Future in the MCU
After No Way Home’s emotional finale, debate rages over whether Zendaya’s MJ should return to Spider-Man’s world or if it’s time for a new chapter. Here’s what fans are saying.
The aftermath of Spider-Man: No Way Home left audiences reeling, as Peter Parker’s identity was erased from the memories of everyone he cared about—including MJ, portrayed by Zendaya. While some are eager to see how her character might re-enter Peter’s life in the upcoming Spider-Man: Brand New Day, others are wary of undoing the poignant ending that resonated so strongly with viewers.
Fan Theories and New Faces
Speculation has been rife regarding the introduction of a fresh romantic interest for Peter. The rumour mill has been particularly active since Sadie Sink’s casting was announced, though her role remains under wraps. One theory circulating online suggests:
Sadie Sink is Jean Grey, and she will be a brief love interest for Peter Parker. Peter will end the relationship with Jean because he still loves MJ, and Jean will find a way to restore MJ’s memories of Peter by the end of the film.
This idea has sparked lively discussion, with some fans expressing concern that reuniting Peter and MJ would diminish the impact of the previous film’s conclusion. Others question the logic of introducing Jean Grey, a character with little romantic history with Peter in the comics, into the mix.
Mixed Reactions from the Fandom
Many have taken to social media to voice their opinions. Some argue that bringing MJ back would undermine the emotional weight of her farewell, while others suggest it’s time for Peter to move on with a new partner—perhaps Gwen Stacy or another figure from the comics. As one fan put it:
Nooo… this should not happen, first of all It'll ruin that perfect ending that we got in NWH and secondly they should end MJ's story and introduce someone new, Like sadie playing either Gwen Stacy or other love interests that peter had in comics.
Others remain sceptical about the plausibility of Jean Grey’s involvement, pointing out the lack of significant connections between her and Peter in established storylines. The notion of mutants suddenly appearing in Peter’s world has also been met with raised eyebrows.
Debate Over MJ’s Place in Peter’s Story
Despite the divided opinions, there are those who feel Zendaya’s character still has a vital role to play. At the close of No Way Home, Peter’s promise to reveal the truth to MJ after Doctor Strange’s spell left a lingering sense of unfinished business. The heartbreak of their separation, coupled with Peter’s isolation after losing his closest friends and family, has left some viewers hoping for a glimmer of hope in his future.
Yet, the argument persists that allowing MJ to return would prevent both Peter and the franchise from evolving. Introducing new characters could offer fresh directions for the story, but the emotional cost of Peter’s sacrifice remains a sticking point for many.
What Lies Ahead for Spider-Man?
With Spider-Man: Brand New Day set for release in July 2026, the debate shows no sign of abating. The cast includes Tom Holland, Zendaya, Jacob Batalon, Sadie Sink, and several others, under the direction of Destin Daniel Cretton. Whether MJ’s journey continues or concludes, fans remain deeply invested in the fate of Peter Parker’s heart.
Spider-Man: Brand New Day is currently scheduled to be released on 31 July 2026.