Movies

Johnny Depp’s dark Christmas Carol is winning over audiences for the reason critics hate it

Johnny Depp’s dark Christmas Carol is winning over audiences for the reason critics hate it
Image credit: Google Veo 3

A darker take on A Christmas Carol has critics and audiences at odds — and, awkwardly, for much the same reasons.

Right, you might think nobody’d dare poke at A Christmas Carol again—how many bloody Scrooges have we had already? But here comes another, and this time it’s Johnny Depp as Ebenezer, under the watchful, possibly sinister eye of Ti West. Yes, the same bloke who’s been scaring the life out of everyone with the X trilogy. If that pairing seems a bit odd to you, you’re not alone—gothic horror meets Dickens usually means someone’s getting sacked, not holiday cheer, but that’s exactly what they’ve done.

This one’s called Ebenezer: A Christmas Carol, and it’s out as of 12th November. The film’s already managed to split opinion clean down the middle. Critics? Mixed as an airport breakfast, fretting over West’s decision to really lean in to the ghost story—actual spectral business, not just ‘ooh look, Marley’s in chains!’ kind of fluff. A few reckon it’s squeezed all the warmth out of Dickens, while others think it finally does the spookiness justice. Audiences, meanwhile, are apparently lapping it up. Rotten Tomatoes is full of genuine punters leaving glowing reviews—proper fan reception, not just bots or ‘my cousin made this’ stuff.

Welcome back Johnny Depp! This version of A Christmas Carol is darker and grittier than the standard which makes Scrooge's redemption all the more compelling and impactful.

That’s Jeffrey, one of the verified audience voices, not fainting at the horror but actually crediting it for making Scrooge’s turnaround stick. And he’s not the only one hailing Depp’s big return to the limelight; after his legal troubles, this is Depp’s first lead role on a cinema screen in ages, so folk are reading it as a comeback—if you’ve missed Jack Sparrow, there are plenty finding echoes here, for better or worse. The Sweeney Todd comparisons keep cropping up too (which, frankly, is not the worst Depp-to-Dickens connective tissue). One Jennifer went to the cinema expecting daftness and came out in tears—not exactly what she was after, but a good sign if you want your Dickens with proper emotional gut-punch.

And it’s not just Depp pulling in the praise. The ghosts themselves are getting mentions nearly every time—Marley’s sequence in particular, and the Ghost of Christmas Present, apparently a ‘perfect 10’ according to at least one adoring ticket holder. The darkness, which had critics wringing their hands, is the very thing punters seem to think sets this adaptation apart—‘Very dark movie. Unlike other Scrooge movies,’ says Denise C, who sounds downright chuffed about it.

Ebenezer: A Christmas Carol opened 12 November 2026 and has quickly divided critics and thrilled audiences.

Will it actually hang about for the whole festive season, or is it too much doom and gloom to become new holiday telly tradition? Hard to say—Christmas films that don’t play it safe aren’t unheard of, but historically, it’s the sugary ones that keep getting wheeled out year after year. Still, when’s the last time you saw a version of Scrooge that felt properly haunted, rather than just a lesson for schoolkids?

CineCorner UK use of cookies We use necessary cookies to make our site work. We'd also like to set analytics cookies that help us make improvements by measuring how you use the site. These will be set only if you accept. For more detailed information about the cookies we use, see our Cookie Policy