How True Grit Breathed New Life Into the Western

In 2010, Matt Damon took on a key role in Ethan and Joel Coen’s reimagining of the Western classic, True Grit. The film, widely regarded as a standout of its genre in recent decades, centres on the determined Mattie Ross, played by Hailee Steinfeld, as she seeks justice for her father’s murder. Enlisting the help of the grizzled Rooster Cogburn, portrayed by Jeff Bridges, and Damon’s Texas Ranger LaBoeuf, the trio set out on a pursuit that forges unexpected bonds along the way.

True Grit not only rekindled interest in Westerns but also achieved remarkable critical acclaim, earning ten nominations at the 83rd Academy Awards. Steinfeld’s performance, particularly impressive given it was her first major film appearance, drew significant praise and a nomination for Best Supporting Actress.

Reinventing a Classic: The Coen Brothers’ Approach

Many Westerns have faded into obscurity, yet the Coen brothers’ adaptation of Charles Portis’ novel managed to distinguish itself. Their version remained faithful to the source material while establishing its own distinct identity, a feat that set it apart from the 1969 film directed by Henry Hathaway and starring John Wayne. The earlier adaptation was well received and even secured an Oscar nomination for Best Original Song, but the consensus among enthusiasts is that the 2010 film surpasses its predecessor.

The Coens’ take on the story introduced creative flourishes that enhanced the narrative, supported by a stellar cast, Carter Burwell’s evocative score, and Roger Deakins’ striking cinematography. The result was a film that not only honoured the original novel but also stood as a remarkable achievement in its own right.

Public Verdict: A Modern Favourite

Fans have been vocal in their preference for the Coen brothers’ version.

“The people have spoken, and they chose the Coen Brothers’ remake as the ultimate winner of this debate. Do you agree?”

The film’s ability to balance respect for its source with inventive storytelling has cemented its place as a modern classic. The performances, particularly Steinfeld’s, have been singled out for acclaim, with many expressing surprise that she did not receive greater recognition during awards season.

Despite the film’s strengths, it faced stiff competition at the Oscars. The 83rd Academy Awards saw True Grit up against a formidable line-up, including Winter’s Bone, Toy Story 3, The Social Network, 127 Hours, The Kids Are All Right, Inception, The King’s Speech, Black Swan, and The Fighter. Ultimately, the top prize went to The King’s Speech, a historical drama focusing on King George VI.

Oscar Night: Recognition Without Reward

True Grit was nominated in ten categories: Best Picture, Best Director, Best Actor, Best Supporting Actress, Best Adapted Screenplay, Best Art Direction, Best Cinematography, Best Costume Design, Best Sound Editing, and Best Sound Mixing. Despite this impressive tally, the film left the ceremony without a single win, a result that continues to baffle and frustrate many viewers.

There remains a sense that the film, and Steinfeld in particular, deserved more from the Academy.

“People are angry and still believe that at least Steinfeld should have bagged an award for her praiseworthy portrayal of Mattie.”

The shutout was especially striking given the film’s critical and commercial success, with a box office total exceeding $250 million and high ratings from both critics and audiences.

Legacy and Where to Watch

True Grit’s impact on the Western genre is undeniable, breathing new life into a style of storytelling that had been considered past its prime. The film’s blend of tradition and innovation, along with its memorable performances and technical achievements, have ensured its lasting appeal. For those wishing to revisit or discover the film, the 2010 version is available to stream on Paramount+ via Prime Video, while the original can be found on MGM+ via Prime Video.