Enemy ending explained: the giant spider makes sense the moment you replay what Adam's mother said
Denis Villeneuve's Toronto thriller ends on an image that looks like a non sequitur and isn't. The key is a short, unremarkable visit Adam pays to his mother about two-thirds of the way in.
Villeneuve closes his 2013 film on a shot that sent a lot of people straight to the internet. The explanation is already in the movie, delivered flatly over a bowl of blueberries.
Adam Bell is a history lecturer in Toronto. Anthony Claire is a bit-part actor with the same face, the same voice and the same scar. The film spends ninety minutes letting you assume these are two men who have found each other, then spends its final shot suggesting the arithmetic was wrong from the start. The scene that settles it isn't the ending. It's the one where Adam drives out to see his mother.
What the mother actually says
Isabella Rossellini's character does three things in a single short scene. She tells Adam she has only one son. She reminds him he has a nice apartment and a decent life. And she tells him to give up the fantasy of being a third-rate movie actor.
That last line is the load-bearing one. Adam is a professor. Anthony is the actor. The mother is talking to one man and referring to both jobs, and she does it without a pause, as if there's nothing to reconcile. Nobody in the film ever corroborates that Adam and Anthony exist separately. The mother is the only person who has known the character since birth, and she counts to one.
The spider was never a twist
Villeneuve seeds the image from the first scene onward, well before the final shot has any chance to land as a shock:
- The underground club — the film opens on a woman about to crush a tarantula under her heel while men watch.
- The skyline — a spider the size of an office block steps over Toronto in a dream sequence.
- The wires — Adam's tram commute is shot through overhead cabling that reads as web.
- The windshield — the car crash leaves a spiderweb fracture in the glass, the film's most literal joining of the two images.
- The bedroom — the last shot, after Adam opens a letter meant for Anthony and finds the key to the club.
By the time the tarantula is standing against the bedroom wall, the film has trained you for it about six times. Adam's reaction is the tell: he sighs, the way you do at something you've dealt with before.
So is Anthony real?
Villeneuve has never closed the question off entirely, but he has made clear which reading he built the film around.
"You don't know if they are two in reality, or maybe from a subconscious point of view, there's just one," Villeneuve said of the two characters in 2014.
Jake Gyllenhaal, who plays both, has been less ambiguous about what he was acting.
"It's about a man who is married, his wife is pregnant, and he's having an affair. He has to figure himself out before he can commit to life as an adult," Gyllenhaal said in 2014.
Read that way, the whole structure snaps into place. Anthony is the version of the man who cheats; Adam is the version who teaches classes on totalitarian control and repetition and doesn't notice he's describing himself. The pregnancy is the deadline. The spider is what commitment looks like from inside the avoidance — and it's worth noting that Helen, six months pregnant, is the one the film turns into it.
The source, and the epigraph
The film adapts José Saramago's 2002 novel The Double, loosely. Villeneuve has said the best way to respect an author is to be honest about the adaptation and "totally destroy the original and make it your own," which is roughly what happens: Saramago's book has no spiders in it at all.
What the film does keep is Saramago's line, which it puts on screen before anything else happens: chaos is order yet undeciphered.
For the record: Enemy took five Canadian Screen Awards, including Best Director, and the Toronto Film Critics Association named it the best Canadian film of 2014. It also sits at 72% on Rotten Tomatoes, which is a fairly polite number for a film that ends the way it does.
Read more: If I Had Legs I'd Kick You ending explained: why you never see the daughter's face until the beach