Apple TV’s new heist thriller has toppled Slow Horses — despite sharply divided reviews
Early buzz around the latest thriller has already hardened into proper chart momentum — the kind you don’t rack up by accident.
Apple TV+ has clearly decided thrillers are the way forward. After quietly amassing a surprisingly strong selection in that department, including the reliably popular Slow Horses and the Idris Elba vehicle Hijack, the streaming service now finds itself with another hit on its hands—regardless of what the critics think. The latest arrival is 12 12 12, a glossy international heist drama fronted by Anthony Mackie and Jamie Dornan. Apparently, viewers are hooked straight out of the gate.
12 12 12 debuted on Apple TV just two days ago and has already shot to No. 1 on the US streaming chart, elbowing aside previous genre favourites and even overtaking Ted Lasso and Slow Horses.
The Show Itself
This one's been pitched as 'Heat meets Christopher Nolan,' which is honestly apt. You've got the classic battle of wits between a driven lawman (Mackie plays a disgraced FBI agent) and a master criminal (Dornan as his sharp-suited nemesis), plus a timeline trick straight out of Dunkirk—each episode slices up the action across three tracks: the year spent plotting the heist, the twelve hours actually pulling it off, and a tense twelve days as everyone tries to vanish before the trail runs cold. Allegedly, that's some FBI rule of thumb, though it sounds a bit more TV logic than reality. Still, it's the kind of high-concept scaffolding that genre series thrive on, and it definitely keeps things moving along.
The show is the brainchild of Jim Keeble and Dudi Appleton, with Kari Skogland (who worked with Mackie on The Falcon and the Winter Soldier) helming the pilot and a few episodes. Plot-wise, the whole thing revolves around an extremely complicated bank job underneath Zurich, but it's really about the cat-and-mouse between the two leads as they skip from one lavish European locale to the next. Both Mackie and Dornan are executive producers, for what it's worth, so they're even more invested than usual.
Critical Backlash (and Praise)
If you're only half-convinced by all this, the critics are right there with you. The reviews so far are wildly polarised. On Rotten Tomatoes it's sitting at a respectable-but-not-exactly-glowing 63%, with the most pointed debates circling around whether the show's structure is clever or just showing off. One reviewer called it "Apple TV's best action thriller yet" (high praise), while another slammed the show as "an increasingly irritating series of unexciting twists leading to an unsatisfying conclusion" (not so glowing). The recurring complaint? The format is doing all the heavy lifting, leaving Mackie and Dornan playing types instead of people. On the upside, everyone seems to agree it looks expensive and doesn't drag, which is not nothing in this market.
Although 12 12 12 seems to be hoovering up eyeballs, the real test will be whether it actually keeps the top spot through its finale on 25 December, since the usual weekly episode drop can bleed excitement, and word is the back half tries viewers' patience even more.
- 12 12 12 is an eight-part series, with the finale airing Christmas Day.
- The show is created by Jim Keeble and Dudi Appleton, and the pilot is directed by Kari Skogland.
- Anthony Mackie and Jamie Dornan star and executive produce the series.
- Its distinctive time-split structure follows 12 months planning, 12 hours for the heist itself, and 12 days as fallout.
- Reception is divided, with a Rotten Tomatoes score around 63% and notable split between 'stylish fun' and 'flat archetypes.'